Apple – Better Late Than Never

Apple is still far behind in the agent business

  • People are starting to use AI services and AI agents on iPhones, but none of them belongs to Apple, which is a hole that Apple must plug if it wants to mitigate the risk that smartphones are replaced by AI agents as the centre of the digital universe.
  • Fortunately for Apple, this is a slow process, and it will be some time before users start to select their devices based on the AI services that they offer as opposed to choosing between Android and iOS.
  • It is clear from looking at the App Store charts where the direction of travel is, as Muse (Meta AI Agent), ChatGPT, and Claude are all now firm fixtures in the top 10, with more to come.
  • OpenAI is expanding the functionality of its agent Dots, while Anthropic is testing its agent Duet, Google has a new version of its agent called Tasks, and SpaceX is pushing hard with Grok Bot.
  • This is pretty much the same playbook that we saw 14 years ago when the mobile ecosystem was emerging, and there were lots of offerings all bidding to be the place where users live their digital lives.
  • Only iOS, Android and WeChat survived, and I think it is likely that the same story is about to be repeated once again.
  • Last time around, Apple and Google were the challengers and had nothing to lose, but this time they are the incumbents, which makes life much more difficult.
  • This is because an incumbent facing a challenge will always be more risk-averse due to the legacy business that it has built, which always puts the incumbent at a disadvantage.
  • However, when incumbency is correctly leveraged, it is very powerful, as in Google’s case, where it has 3bn+ users that it can push its AI services to and have them set as the default.
  • Default is also a very powerful tool, as the vast majority of users will never change it, making adoption much easier as long as the new feature is good enough.
  • This is where Apple has a problem, as its AI is third-rate, as the execrable Siri keeps on reminding me.
  • Furthermore, by posting job openings now for the posts of creating proactive agents, it shows just how far it is behind.
  • So far this is not a problem because users are still not making their selection of ecosystem based on agents and the cross-device stickiness of iPhone, Mac, Watch and so on will also go some way to holding the ecosystem together.
  • However, if there comes a time when the agent on the device carries out most of the digital life services on behalf of the user, then preference will shift to the agent and away from the smartphone ecosystem.
  • This will especially be the case as most agents (Dots, Muse, Duet, etc.) will be available to an equivalent standard of quality on all ecosystems.
  • It will be at this point that users will wonder why they are paying a premium for Apple for much less perceivable benefit, which is why Apple must produce a top-notch agent and ensure that it is only available on Apple products.
  • As far as Apple, OpenAI and Google are concerned, this is a must-win, as failure to be a leading agent beloved by users will mean commoditisation and heavy pressure on gross margin.
  • Apple still has time and incumbency, so I think that this is achievable, but if it is only just starting to hire for this now, one might start to think that it is moving too slowly.
  • At the moment, Apple’s lack of exposure to AI is providing it with a safe haven status as the sentiment towards the AI trade continues to sour, but this is not enough to justify its premium valuation in my opinion.
  • Apple shares are trading at 36.7x 12-month forward PER, which is nearly 4x Nvidia, while offering a paltry 6% growth rate.
  • There remains much better value to be had elsewhere.

RICHARD WINDSOR

Richard is founder, owner of research company, Radio Free Mobile. He has 16 years of experience working in sell side equity research. During his 11 year tenure at Nomura Securities, he focused on the equity coverage of the Global Technology sector.

Leave a Comment